How to Journal for Overthinking

Imagine you are planning a dinner party for a group of friends. You’ve spent a lot of time planning the menu, decorating the house, and making sure everything is perfect.

The night of the party arrives, and your friends come over. Everyone seems to be having a great time, enjoying the food and the ambiance.

However, one of your friends, let’s call her Sonia, makes an offhand comment about how the dessert could have been better or suggests an alternative dish that might have been a better choice.

During the party, you feel pleased with how things are going.

However, Sonia’s comment about the dessert sticks in your mind. Despite the overall success of the event and the positive feedback from most of your friends, your brain fixates on Sonia’s critical comment.

Once the party is over and you are cleaning up, you can’t stop thinking about Sonia’s comment. You replay the moment in your mind, wondering if the dessert really wasn’t good enough.

You start to ruminate: Was the dessert really that bad? Should I have chosen a different recipe? Did everyone else think the same but didn’t say anything?

These thoughts loop without leading to any constructive conclusion.

Your thoughts spiral into worst-case scenarios: What if everyone secretly agreed with Sonia but was too polite to say anything? What if they think I’m a terrible host? What if they don’t want to come to my parties in the future?

The more you think about it, the more you start to doubt your abilities as a host. You feel anxious about planning such events in the future, worrying that you’ll face similar criticisms.

This cycle of overthinking can lead to physical symptoms like tension headaches or trouble sleeping due to stress. Emotionally, you feel disappointed, insecure, and less excited about hosting events in the future.

Does this sound familiar to you? Have you ever been in a situation where one negative comment or event overshadowed all the positive feedback and left you doubting yourself?

If so, you’re not alone. It happens to so many of us.

Overthinking can take a small negative event or comment and amplify its importance, leading to a cycle of rumination, self-doubt, and anxiety that impacts both our mental and physical well-being.

a girl writing her overthinking journal — Photo by Brent Gorwin on Unsplash

Overthinking is very common in today’s fast-paced, high-pressure lives.

Whether it’s worrying about a comment at a dinner party, replaying a work mistake, or agonizing over a social media post, our minds have a way of blowing things out of proportion.

We focus on the negative, dwell on what went wrong, and let it overshadow all the good.

This process of dwelling only on the negative things over time makes us feel sad, depressed, and anxious.

Among other things like therapy, one of the best tools that can help you overcome such feelings is journaling because it allows you to dump whatever is there in your head onto a piece of paper.

You can then see that from a distance and form a different perspective. You can detach yourself from those thoughts. You can identify patterns and find ways to deal with them.

Welcome back to our journaling series. If this is your first blog, we invite you to read the previous blogs of this series after this one.

In this blog, we’ll talk about how you can journal to manage overthinking.

So, if you’re ready to take control of your thoughts and stop overthinking, keep reading. Journaling might just be the tool you need to find peace of mind.

What is Overthinking?

Let’s revisit the dinner party scenario we just talked about.

Despite the overall success of the event and the positive feedback from most of your friends, your brain fixates on Sonia’s comment about the dessert.

This is because of the negativity bias that makes us focus more on the negative information and things.

You replay the moment repeatedly, wondering if the dessert really wasn’t good enough, and begin to ruminate.

Your thoughts spiral into worst-case scenarios: What if everyone secretly agreed with Sonia? What if they think I’m a terrible host? This cycle continues and results in self-doubt and unnecessary stress.

This is overthinking in action.

Overthinking often happens with people who are highly sensitive, and being highly sensitive is actually a positive trait.

Sensitive people have a unique ability to process thoughts, emotions, and experiences deeply and intricately.

This heightened awareness allows them to notice details others might overlook and to reflect on them thoughtfully. However, this same depth of processing can sometimes lead to overthinking.

Overthinking is when you dwell on thoughts for too long. It can involve conjuring up worst-case scenarios, obsessing over your choices, or constantly rethinking your actions.

It might happen during those late-night hours when you replay the day’s events in your head, wishing you had done things differently, like returning a call or speaking up in a meeting.

Essentially, your mind keeps running in circles and won’t let you relax.

Does Journaling Help with Overthinking?

Now that we understand overthinking is replaying moments repeatedly in our heads, which makes us imagine worst-case scenarios and doubt our actions, the goal is to break this cycle of rumination.

The best way to deal with mental health conditions is therapy because when you’re dealing with built-up stress and tension, talking to a therapist allows you to unload your thoughts and feelings.

You vent them out in front of a therapist and you immediately feel lighter. If you’ve ever taken therapy, you would know how light and free it feels once you’ve shared your worries and anxieties with someone who listens and understands.

Journaling is the next best thing to therapy.

You’re doing the same thing, just on a piece of paper instead of in front of a therapist.

Journaling is a process of unloading whatever is there in your head, be it thoughts related to what happened a week ago, how you feel about a certain event, situation, or person, or what’s going to happen tomorrow.

By writing them down in your journal, you give yourself a way to process and understand them, which can reduce the intensity of overthinking.

You create a safe space for your thoughts and feelings. You don’t have to worry about being judged or misunderstood. This process also helps you get a deeper understanding of yourself and how you feel and react to a certain situation.

Journaling is the perfect tool to unload your mind and gain some much-needed calm and clarity.

How to Calm Your Mind from Overthinking with Journaling?

Since the whole idea is to calm our mind and stop it from playing the same thoughts in a loop, let’s take a look at how journaling can help with overthinking.

Journaling Helps in Practicing Mindfulness

One of the primary ways in which journaling can help is by cultivating mindfulness.

Mindfulness is a practice that encourages you to stay in the present moment without thinking about what happened in the past and what’s going to happen in the future.

It is a practice that grounds you in the present.

When you journal, you are focused on the present moment. You don’t think about the worries of the past and the uncertainties of the future.

You reflect on what happened today, how it made you feel, and what you learned from it.

Mindfulness is a much bigger concept and if you want to learn about it in detail, here are a few blogs on this topic.

Journaling Helps in Practicing Gratitude

Another way in which journaling can help is through its ability to help you practice gratitude.

Gratitude is a practice that shifts your mind from what you don’t have in your life to what you have. It reminds you of the good things and the positive aspects of your life.

This changes your perspective towards things and when you regularly notice these positive aspects, you train your mind to seek out and focus on the good things in life.

This helps in counteracting the negativity bias that fuels overthinking.

Here are a few blogs if you want to learn more about gratitude and how you can practice it in your everyday life:

Mindfulness and Gratitude: Powerful Tools for Mental Health

Mindfulness and gratitude are two practices that have tremendous benefits on your mental health. If there are two practices that can help you deal with almost all lifestyle-related mental health problems, they are mindfulness and gratitude.

Meditation and journaling are the two main tools for these practices.

While meditation teaches you how to control your thoughts and stay present, journaling helps you vent out whatever is there in your head and get clarity on your thoughts and feelings.

Journaling Shifts Your Focus

Journaling also helps you shift your focus to the things that actually matter.

It gives you a space to explore the things you want to achieve, your goals, your dream life, and the aspects of your life you find most meaningful.

This can be particularly helpful when you find yourself caught up in overthinking trivial matters.

It gives you clarity on the things that actually matter instead of dwelling on little things from everyday life that have no importance at all.

Instead of feeling low and sad by minor inconveniences or negative comments, you start to focus on your larger goals and the progress you are making towards them.

It helps you focus on where you should be directing all your thoughts, energy, and efforts.

How to Start Journaling for Overthinking?

Let’s now talk step-by-step about how you can start journaling to break the cycle of rumination.

1. Start with Morning Pages

If you’ve never journaled before, one of the best ways to start is with morning pages, a technique popularized by Julia Cameron in her book The Artist’s Way. This is freestyle writing, where you let your thoughts flow freely onto the paper.

The purpose of morning pages is to clear your mind of clutter and start your day with a clean slate.

Your mind is often full of thoughts from the previous day, worries about the day ahead, and random musings. The idea is to dump whatever is there in your head onto a piece of paper so you feel relaxed and light.

Start by finding a quiet place in the morning where you won’t be interrupted. Don’t overthink what you’re writing, just let the words flow.

It might be a jumble of random thoughts, feelings, dreams, or even mundane details about your plans for the day.

The key is to keep writing without judging or overthinking about what to write or what you’re writing. Don’t worry if you don’t reach three pages or if you go beyond that. The goal is to unload whatever is there in your head.

If mornings are too hectic, you can write your pages at any other time of the day that works for you.

The idea is to use this exercise as a mental dump, a way to transfer all the thoughts swirling in your head onto paper.

Once your thoughts are written down, you can look at them from a distance and challenge them. You might notice patterns, identify irrational thoughts, or see things from a different perspective you didn’t think of.

2. Choose the Type of Journaling You Want to Continue With

Morning pages are a great way to get started but they are just one type of journaling among many. As you become more comfortable with this practice, you’ll see that journaling can help with other areas of your life as well.

Once you read the previous blogs of this journaling series we’ve shared above, you’ll understand that there are so many different types and benefits of journaling.

It can be used for personal growth, self-improvement, practicing mindfulness and gratitude, manifesting your dream life, and so much more.

It is a multifaceted concept with immense benefits in different aspects of your life, and you can use it to improve your overall existence.

As you explore these different types of journaling, you might want to try other methods or use it for other purposes as well. Or you might want to try a combination of different things.

So the next step for you is to identify whether you just want to journal to counter overthinking or you want to use it for improving other aspects of your existence as well.

If it’s just to counter overthinking, the morning pages technique will work just fine but if you want to use it to improve other areas of your existence as well, the next step is to identify the larger objectives.

Maybe you can start with the morning pages or free-flow writing, which will give you an excellent foundation, and as you become more comfortable with this practice, you can gradually evolve this habit into a practice that enriches every aspect of your existence.

3. Make Journaling a Ritual, a Daily Habit

To make sure that journaling becomes a consistent part of your life, create a ritual around it.

One of the best ways to do that is to pair it with something else you enjoy doing.

For example, you can write your morning pages while having your morning tea, coffee, or any healthy beverage of your choice. This pairing makes the process more enjoyable and something you look forward to each day.

Sit quietly in a cozy corner of your home, sip your drink, and write your journal. If mornings don’t work for you, do the same in the evening or any other time of the day.

Make your journaling space inviting and relaxing. Light a candle or use ambient lighting to create a soothing environment.

You can maybe play some soft background music like sounds of nature or water.

4. Be Consistent

Journaling is not something that will give you instant and dramatic results.

While you might feel a sense of relief and calm immediately after a brain-dump session, you’ll see the actual benefits when it is practiced consistently over time.

So, like any other habit, the key to reaping its maximum benefits is in making it a regular part of your routine.

As we discussed in the previous point, create a ritual around it and set a specific time each day for journaling, even if it’s just for a few minutes.

Start small if it’s too overwhelming initially, even writing for five minutes a day will make a lot of difference. But make sure you commit to doing it regularly.

Consider it a long-term investment in your well-being. Just as you won’t get fit after just a few workout sessions, don’t expect to see immense changes in your mental state after only a few journaling sessions.

Give yourself time and be patient with the process.

Over time, you’ll see how journaling helps you manage your thoughts, reduce stress, and gain clarity on things.

Also, consistency is not about perfection.

There will be days when you miss a session or struggle to find the words. That’s perfectly normal. The goal is not to journal perfectly but to maintain a regular practice that supports your mental health.

Be kind to yourself on those off days and gently return to your routine when you can.

5. Reflect and Review

On top of being consistent in your journaling practice, it’s equally important to take some time to reflect and review what you’ve written.

Looking back at your journal entries will help you identify recurring themes and patterns in your thinking.

You might notice that certain situations or thoughts trigger your overthinking more than others. Recognizing these patterns is the first step toward addressing and managing them.

For example, you might find that social situations consistently cause you anxiety, or that self-doubt creeps in whenever you take on new challenges.

You can cope with them more effectively if you’re aware of these triggers.

So, set aside some time, perhaps once a month to review your journal and what you’ve written.

While doing so, look for patterns in your entries, note any significant changes in your thoughts or feelings, and acknowledge your progress.

This doesn’t have to be a lengthy or formal process, even a brief review can give you valuable insights.

How Do You Make an Overthinking Journal?

Making an overthinking journal and choosing the type of journal can significantly impact how comfortable and motivated you feel to write regularly.

If you decide to follow the morning pages method, where you write freely about anything that comes to mind, a plain notebook with blank pages is all you need.

This method allows for unrestricted, stream-of-consciousness writing, letting your thoughts flow naturally onto the page without any specific structure.

However, if staring at a blank page feels overwhelming and intimidating, you can go for a guided journal with prompts and sections.

These prompts can be questions about your day or reflections on your feelings about specific topics.

You decide whichever type of journal you’re comfortable with.

What Should You Write When Overthinking?

As we discussed above, when you’re caught in the loop of overthinking, one of the best ways to break free is to write down everything that’s on your mind.

You don’t have to worry about grammar, structure, or making sense, just write whatever comes to mind.

Keep going until you feel like you’ve gotten it all out, but try to stop before you start rehashing the same thoughts over and over.

Start by describing what’s currently bothering you. With overthinking, it’s often not what’s happening right now that’s causing stress, but rather your worries about what could happen in the future.

Write about what’s happening in the present moment and acknowledge that what’s really stressful is the uncertainty of what might come next.

This realization can itself be a relief and can help you see the difference between actual events and your fears about them.

Once you’re done writing, take some time to reflect on what you’ve written and ask yourself if things could be different.

Is there something you can do about it? This kind of self-questioning can help you regain a sense of control and clarity.

Here are some questions you might want to ask yourself:

How sure are you that what you fear will actually happen and how do you know?
If it does happen, could it be not as bad as you think?
Is there something you could do to turn things around?

You can reduce your anxiety by asking such questions and challenging your thoughts in this way.

It helps you realize that the worst-case scenarios you’re imagining are often less likely or less terrible than they seem.

Wrapping Up – Does Journaling Help With Overthinking?

It’s okay if you’re an overthinker. Overthinking isn’t always a bad thing. It often means you’re highly sensitive and notice details others might miss. This can in fact be a strength that helps you solve problems and see the bigger picture.

Overthinking becomes a problem when our natural negativity bias takes hold. This trait, which once helped our ancestors stay safe from danger, can make us dwell on small negative things in today’s world.

For example, you might fixate on one negative comment from a colleague while ignoring all the positive ones, which leads to stress and self-doubt.

It’s important to understand that certain tendencies, like the negativity bias, are simply part of being human.

While we don’t face the same dangers our ancestors did, our minds still have those old survival mechanisms. Understanding this can help us be kinder to ourselves when we start overthinking.

Our minds are very complex, and there’s still so much we don’t understand about why we think and feel the way we do.

However, we do have control over how we respond to our thoughts. Finding effective ways to manage overthinking is within our power, and one of the best tools for this is journaling.

As we’ve discussed, journaling can help break the cycle of overthinking.

We encourage you to incorporate journaling into your daily routine. Over time, you’ll likely find that it helps you manage overthinking and improves other areas of your life as well.

If you have experiences or insights about overthinking and journaling that you’d like to share, please do so in the comments. We’d love to hear from you and learn together. Namaste!

Welcome to Sage and Sirius

Browse the Blog

How to Journal for Overthinking

Table of Contents

What is Overthinking?

Does Journaling Help with Overthinking?

How to Calm Your Mind from Overthinking with Journaling?